Friday, February 6, 2015

Writing Historical Mysteries

by Carola Dunn
Bestselling author

I have been writing historical  novels for thirty years. If you count the 1960s as  historical--opinions differ!--I have had more than fifty published. Of these, thirty-two are Regencies.. The other eighteen are mysteries, the seventeen titles of my Daisy Dalrymple series, set in the 1920s, [including] Manna from Hades, the first of a new series of Cornish mysteries set in the 1960s.

There are both advantages and disadvantages to setting a mystery in the past. On the one hand, you don't have to worry about the latest advances in forensic science and technology overtaking the publication of your books. However, obviously, it takes more efforts to find out the methods used to solve crimes in the past.

Where the 1920s are concerned, it's easy to find countless mysteries written at that time which have more or less accurate information about detective techniques. For information about English police techniques, straight from the horses' mouths, the memoirs of Scotland Yard detectives are available, e.g. G.W. Cornish of Scotland Yard, as well as Mostly Murder by the great forensic pathologist Sir Sidney Smith.

The more distant from the present the period you choose to write about, the less accurate information is available. Of course, you don't have to go far back to find that the science of forensics didn't exist. Those responsible for detecting criminals were not expected to provide anything we would call real proof. A book well worth hunting out is Clues! (UK: Written in Blood) A History of Forensic Detection by Colin Watson.

In twenty-first century America, guilty verdicts are quite often proved incorrect when genetic evidence is considered. You can imagine how frequent miscarriages of justice were in the past.

Luckily, the less information is available, the more leeway for the fiction writer.

Creating an impression of the spirit of the times is, in my opinion, the most important job for any historical fiction writer mystery or other. If you're writing about Ancient Rome, your characters have to take slavery for granted; in mid-nineteenth century America, they should not. Religion reigned supreme in medieval Europe, even kings seeking the blessing of the papacy. To the upper classes of eighteen century England and France, manners and etiquette were of enormous importance, even in dire circumstances.

The class system was an unavoidable aspect of nineteenth century England that can't be ignored, however little you like it. America in the nineteenth century boasted a feeling of boundless opportunity--unless you were a slave. The Depression era depressed not only economic life but people's spirits and expectations. Wherever and whenever until quite recently, and still now in many parts of the globe, women were subservient.

All these aspects of society influenced the way people thought and behave and have to be a major part of your setting. They will change the motives for and kinds of crimes that are committed. Just consider one example: blackmail. These days, you couldn't blackmail someone for living "in sin." Too many people do it openly!


Ramla Zareen said...


I came across this blog through Goodreads, and would just like to take this opportunity to comment that I am finding it very interesting...!

Moreover, I would also like to mention that Daisy Dalrymple series is one of favourite mystery series...! :-) And I really enjoyed reading this post by one of my favourite authors :-)

Thanks a lot for this wonderful blog...!

Ramla Zareen

Unknown said...

She couldve replied to your compliment.